How to Prepare for a Performance Review — and Act on the Feedback to Accelerate Your Career
Performance reviews are among the most important conversations you’ll have in your professional life. They offer a structured opportunity to reflect on your achievements, align expectations with your manager, and set clear goals for the future. Yet for many professionals, reviews can feel stressful, one‑sided or even meaningless if there’s no clear plan for follow‑up. With the right preparation and approach to feedback, you can turn every performance review into a career‑building milestone.
Why a Performance Review Matters
Your review is an opportunity to show how your work supports the firm’s clients, revenue, compliance obligations and internal operations — not just your job description.
Performance reviews should be two‑way conversations that:
Assess your contribution and quality of work
Provide structured feedback on strengths and development areas
Develop and discuss your professional goals
Enable career planning, including discussions about promotions, role expansion, and remuneration.
Rather than viewing this process as a judgment, consider it a strategic moment to empower growth, celebrate your successes and gain valuable feedback.
Before the Review — Preparation Is Key
If you want to get the most out of your review, be proactive and purposeful in your approach. SEEK offers jobseekers a practical preparation framework:
1. Understand the Process
Different organisations use different review formats — from structured templates to informal conversations. Clarify the process details and structure with your manager or HR team ahead of time.
2. Reflect on Achievements
Record your key accomplishments since your last review. Where possible, quantify outcomes — time saved, increased efficiency, or improved client feedback. This builds credibility and positions you to discuss progression confidently.
3. Assess Strengths and Development Areas
Conduct an honest self‑assessment. Identify the areas where you’ve excelled and those where there’s room for improvement. Examples could include technical upskilling, delegation or client communication. This shows maturity, self‑awareness and commitment to growth.
4. Align with Organisational Goals
Demonstrate how your work supports broader team and company objectives. Consider how your work improves client experience or how you support advisers, partners or senior accountants. This shows strategic thinking and helps managers see your value in context.
5. Set Your Own Agenda
Come prepared with your own objectives: a request for professional development, leadership opportunities, or discussions around remuneration. Be clear on what you’re working towards and why it benefits both you and the firm. This ensures the review covers your goals as well as performance.
6. Prepare to Receive Feedback
Approach feedback with openness. Performance reviews are not just about what you say but also what you hear. Ask clarifying questions so you understand expectations and areas for improvement.
During the Review — Engage, Clarify, Commit
A performance review should be conversational, not confrontational. When receiving feedback:
Listen actively and take notes
Ask for detailed examples
Respond with professionalism
After the Review — Action Makes the Difference
Feedback has limited value unless you act on it. Transform conversation into momentum with these steps:
1. Create an Action Plan
Translate feedback into SMART goals — Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, and Time‑bound objectives. Include short‑, medium‑ and long‑term milestones tied to concrete actions.
2. Schedule Regular Check‑Ins
Instead of waiting for your next annual review, schedule regular catch‑ups with your manager to discuss progress. Proactive check-ins keep expectations aligned and demonstrate ownership of your development.
3. Communicate Progress
Keep a record of improvements and achievements following your review. Sharing progress reinforces your commitment and ensures your efforts are visible when future opportunities arise.
Your Performance Review as a Strategic Career Tool
Preparing thoroughly and actioning feedback reframes performance reviews from administrative tasks into powerful opportunities. Professionals who own their preparation, engage constructively in the conversation and follow up with a clear development plan are better placed to progress in their careers and position themselves as long-term assets to their organisations.
At Bentley Recruitment, we work closely with professionals and firms across Australia in the accounting, financial services and business support sectorS. We understand what employers look for during performance reviews — and how strong performance conversations often lead to career-defining opportunities.
If you’re preparing for a review or considering your next career move, our consultants can help you align your experience, achievements and goals with the right opportunity.
.png)
